I have just been told by my certifier that adding soap to emulsify neem oil causes saponification which makes "it" synthetic and therefore not allowed (not her exact words) for certified organic. Egads! What next? I will go and try adding Nu Film P (as an adjuvant, not heavens knows, as a saponifer/emulsifier) but don't have much hope. Has anyone tried using something else? I thought I (and you) fell under NOP 205.206 c. Disease problems may be controlled through 2) Application of non synthetic, biological, botanical, or mineral inputs. ergo. compost tea, neem, EM and hosts of other homebrews. Michael has been very careful in almost always suggesting "approved for organic materials" -- maybe a perusal of the appendixes again -- just checked, I don't think even Dr Bronners certified soap would be allowed under this scenario.

Any certified folks out there who have approval for the soap/neem process? Help!

The Apple Farm
Zone 8b in California



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 03/28/2013 09:27PM by Michael Phillips.

I just reread the saponification sentence out loud and found I misinterpreted what the certifier said. She was referring to the soap making process as resulyng in a synthetic product...not me saponifying the neem with soap. I replied to that asking if I made my own soap from lye and fats would I then be a chemist making synthetic product..have not heard back yet. Also Nu film P does not emulsify. Tim

I could say a few things about your particular certifier ... but let's just suggest this person apparently would prefer not to bathe than risk the dangers of good ol' soap. You have hit on the definition of saponification, which is the making of actual soap. Whereas we are using such a little amount of biodegradable soap to emulsify neem oil so it mixes readily into water in the spray tank. I for one am glad you are beyond that attempt with NuFilm to do the same.

Some certifiers accept the use of Ecover and Seventh Generation dishwashing soap -- both "natural" brands -- to emulsify neem. This is what I use, one quarter cup liquid soap to a half gallon of pure neem oil. Other certifers insist it be Dr. Bronners, and then the baby formulation (or some such), which being a weaker soap, requires at least double the rate. The issue here is not that these soaps use dangerous ingredients to clean the plates from which we eat, but rather that OMRI has no reason to test the benign. Nor do these companies have any reason to pay the fees required for the testing. You can get coconut soap nuts from Ahimsa Organics to emulsify neem oil, this being the traditional Ayurvedic method. I have not tried this ... because biodegradable soap works so, so fine.

To be blunt: This is a human problem. It has nothing to do with the health of the orchard, the health of the soil, or the nutrient density of the fruit we grow. Organic certification is a choice. I for one do not support the current version.

Lost Nation Orchard
Zone 4b in New Hampshire



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/28/2013 03:15AM by Michael Phillips.

OK, OK. Thanks Michael and for the phone call warning about Nu Film and an even more blunt remark about certifiers. At this point I am too big not to be certified--but I keep thinking about how I can get out and keep my market--another discussion--maybe under marketing. I think (hope) that my certifier would be molified if I can show the approval for this from other certifiers or that saponification is not a synthetic process. I sent Michael the whole dialogue so far with my certifier. Once again does anybody have approval for soap? Maybe Michael knows who? I have been using (Shhhh!)New Age Household Cleaner--Biodegradable and "natural" etc.and more local than Ecover (Belgium) and 7th Gen. (not west coast) etc. Tim

Just happened to think- Safer Insecticidal Soap is OMRI approved, so saponification per se does not exclude something from approval.

Jim Gallott
New Haven, VT USDA Zone 5a

Hmmmm, I had thought about Safer but just in passing and forgot. Thanks for the reminder. I will run it by my certifier--who has gotten strangely silent since I suggested making my own soap (with lye and fat and ashes) would probably not do it either plus no response to Dr Bronner (that request was on Good Friday maybe forgive that one til tomottow)---which if Michael is right that you need twice as much and it is nearly twice the price easily triples the cost. I think I have some safers on hand--will test it's emulsifying effects tomorrow. Priobably even more costly. Certification=Compliance=Itchy Underwear--Lynn Miller Tim

Reporting in--Safers works quite satisfactorily as an emulsifier at pretty much the same rate as New Age or Seventh Generation for me. I have faound that 8-10 oz is enough for a gallon of Neem. If you are bigger like me the product is M-PEDE. Safers only comes in 16-32 oz sizes. So if you are certified Organic you ask to use Safers or M-PEDE as an insecticide and happen to be adding it when putting on your neem to not waste deisel on two different sprays. The timing for aphid control and spring neem sprays is the same--aphids, watch out! I haven't done the cost analysis yet since I don't have the M-PEDE bill yet. I have the MSDS for New Age Soap and will submit to certifier after I make a few inquiries.

I found some OMRI listed soap nuts which my certifier has approved for use - haven't tried them yet (still in the mail) but planning on making a liquid soap from them and using that as an emulsifier.

Looking for some feedback, especially from Tim Bates if possible. We made the jump to holistic orcharding about 4 years ago and have had success. I have been using seventh generation as an emulsifier during this whole time because it is on the OEFFA approved products list, however, through review with our Organic Certifier he mentioned that it is only approved for cleaning with a rinse and should not be in contact with organic land or products. What a head scratcher. So, wanted to spark this conversation back up and see if anyone is aware of an emulsifier that works great with neem oil, won't break the bank, and will make the almighty approvers happy?

Brandt Schisler
Hickory Ridge Orchard
Mexico, MO
Zone 6b

Brandt - Tim is listed in the grower profiles under the Apple Farm if you want to contact him directly. I could be wrong on this but in my experience organic certifiers are now accepting biodegradable soaps for use in emulsifying.

Pommes de Terre Acres
USDA Zone 5 - Dixon, Montana
Intermountain West Region